This seems to be a new trend in parenting. I'm in my mid-30s. When I was a child, typically extended family members did not attend birthday parties. The exception being same-aged cousins might be invited as guests. But now the expectation seems to be that extended family members will attend. My sister is generally speaking a very reasonable mom, but she was really upset when our little brother wasn't going to attend her son's bday party. What late-20s man wants to attend a 3 year old's bday party? I was attending to help out, and b/c I happen to enjoy toddlers. By the time my nephew is 10 or so, I probably won't be going. That seemed to really bug her. But I think kids enjoy hanging out with their friends at their bday parties, not with Aunt and Uncle and Grandma and Grandpa. When my nephew is older, he and I will do something together for his birthday, like lunch and a movie or something.
Parents on the board - how do you feel about this? How did this even become a "thing"?
Nephew's bday was in September, so it's a while off. Sister scheduled it on a day CS had soccer, so Cousin interrupted CS's soccer game to bring him to the bday. No major drama, but that's b/c Mom and I kept a constant eye on CS.
My family always did a family birthday celebration (apart from any friend party). So yeah, we expected everyone to be there. If there were multiple birthdays in a month, they would do them all at once. But it was always scheduled with everyone's input.
I don't expect anyone to come to my kids' parties, because there's the small matter of the international border to be crossed. :P
Actually, we don't do parties at this point, because feeding everyone food and getting candy for a pinata that is allergy-free for my kids is freaking expensive, and I'd rather spend it on a trip as a family. But that will change when they get older and actually care about these things.
I don't have any kids of my own, but have attended family parties for friends' children. I don't think anyone was expected to come - they were just happy to see the relatives that could make it. Teenagers and young adults probably do hate stuff like that, so I'd not hold it against them if they didn't attend.
I 100% agree. I invite my kids friends to their birthday parties. The only people I invite who don't have kids are their grandparents. I don't invite aunts and uncles without kids. If they wanted to come I would invite them and they could come, but I know they probably don't want to. I was willing to attend kids birthday parties before I had kids, but I am the rare exception. Most adults have no such interest.
I always felt sorry for kids that were only allowed to invite a couple friends but had to invite EVERYONE in the family. Because kids are going to have way more fun with their friends than at a family reunion and kids want to play with more than just their cousins. They want to play with their school friends and neighborhood friends and best friends.
The family party and the friend party is a good idea. I suggested that to someone I know who has a LARGE family with lots of in their 20s step sisters and aunts and uncles that want to come celebrate her kids but I don't think they are super thrilled about giving up a Saturday afternoon to go be around a ton of screaming kids running around at a petting zoo. Plus when she invites all her friends with kids and her daughter's friends then the family on top of that it is almost 60+ people. I told her she might want to start doing a family dinner birthday party on like a week night and then just do the party for the kids on a Saturday. A lot of those party venues don't have the room for a bunch of adults without kids to be standing around and they just kinda get in the way and I don't think they are super thrilled to be there either but feel like they have to show up.
Since I don't get along with my DH's family we don't even invite cousins to their parties. But we invite every other kid we know and their whole class sometimes and it ends up being like 30+ kids and they have a great time. They don't even know their cousins and even if we were on speaking terms at most we would only see them once or twice a year so it is not like they would be super close. They are much much closer to their classmates they see in school every day and their neighborhood friends and their playdate friends they see all the time and have known forever.