There are 3 mafia and 1 animal whisperer (sheriff) left. Is that right? Players left for possible mafia:
1.Alice - happy we killed off poacher (benefits mafia slightly more than townies) 2.M&S 3.Aardvark 4.Desde 5.Mischa - happy we killed off poacher (benefits mafia slightly more than townies) 6.Kalikat 7.Uhuh - happy we killed off poacher (benefits mafia slightly more than townies), created tie first phase 8.ORRainy - asked who we thought the poacher was, but didn't ask about mafia
Anyone else have any notes or updates/corrections to my lists?
I would have created ties in second phase but with AG getting 5 votes, there was no way for me to create a tie situation. :(
The only reason why I was happy is because then the game last longer with one kill at night instead of two if poacher wasn't killed.
Can't you tell that I'm addicted to Mafia?
I haven't been on the winning team so far.
What I have noticed is that the quiet ones are usually mafia. At least one of the mafia is super quiet. Kalikat is behaving strange. Usually she would banter with Tigerlily but hasn't so far. What is up with that?
I still have no clue about anyone, so I'll just go on this post.
The weekend got in my way of playing, I'm sorry I missed one voting and yiiipeeee for getting the Poacher!
Now let's see... I really don't think Kali is mafia. She has been very quiet lately and from last game when she was mafia she was a lot more vocal. Now from Tiger post it seems suspicious that two of the persons that are voting for Kali are there marked as possible mafia.
I think that Tiger is right on her suspicions and *maybe* Uhuh and Mischa are in cahoots to get rid of a fellow townie. So:
uhuh, mischa alice and OR were my top ideas for mafia...so i'm not sure if the kali pile-up means that i am completely wrong or that a couple of them are definitely mafia...
uhuh, mischa alice and OR were my top ideas for mafia...so i'm not sure if the kali pile-up means that i am completely wrong or that a couple of them are definitely mafia...
Or maybe the mafia was waiting for somebody to make the first vote and then pile on so that they look innocent? But even I don't buy this flimsy excuse of mine. It doesn't make sense since it was Mischa who found the poacher.
-- Edited by uhuh on Monday 12th of March 2012 07:04:05 PM
But is not also beneficial from mafia to have the Poacher out of the way?
Well, I guess I better get a vote in. Kali could be guilty, but I'm not really feeling it, so I don't want to vote for her. I'm still unsure about uhuh, but she has said a few suspicious things and I'm not suspicious enough of anyone else to branch out right now, so:
lol moon, i was trying to type stuff up while you were posting :)
Why OR? Is it because she asked about the poacher but not mafia? She also was the first to vote for Missy on Day 1, but I don't know if that means much. I'm willing to switch if you think she's a better target than uhuh. Uhuh just always leaves me guessing, and every time I've voted for her she's been innocent. :(
I guess it probably doesn't matter too much at this point, but the more I think about OR asking about the SK but not mafia, the more it seems like an odd thing to do. I keep trying to picture myself doing that, and I can't. I'm always focused on finding the mafia and tend to forget about the SK.
I was using RNG which is how I got Missy. I believe uhuh to be a townie. I am not mafia. I asked about the poacher because no one was asking about the poacher-AG (unsurprisingly now) was focused only on the mafia. Right now I think that Tiger is innocent (except for the fact she voted for me :/) but she could be mafia and they are using up the potions that could be used to save townies...
I was using RNG which is how I got Missy. I believe uhuh to be a townie. I am not mafia. I asked about the poacher because no one was asking about the poacher-AG (unsurprisingly now) was focused only on the mafia. Right now I think that Tiger is innocent (except for the fact she voted for me :/) but she could be mafia and they are using up the potions that could be used to save townies...
I had actually thought of that, but it seems like a very risky move. I'm inclined to believe she really is innocent, at least for now.
Do you have any particular reason for thinking uhuh is a townie? In case it's not obvious by now, I've been wavering on her. :)
I'm not sure about OR either. The pileon for Kali seems suspicious and uhuh wasn't seeming guilty enough to vote for. Any of the people voting following uhuhs vote would be fine with me but I don't think we are able to save Kali anyways.
AAs for suspecting me as mafia - ghosts don't save me tonight if mafia targets me. And decide whichever way you want on whoever else they might pick. Is that good?
What kinda clues could I have given...anything too knowledge able and mafia would kill me. Though that doesn't mean I didn't give clues (y'all just can't read ;p)...